Choosing the best exterior shutters for your home does not have to feel like a guessing game. Our team spent weeks comparing 8 popular vinyl shutter models side by side, weighing fade resistance, build quality, warranty length, and how each one actually looks mounted beside a real window. The result is a buyer-focused guide that walks you through what works in 2026, which styles fit which home, and where each of these shutters earns its place on your house.
Exterior shutters are decorative or functional panels mounted beside (or onto) a window that frame the opening, add architectural character, control light, and historically protected windows from weather and intruders. Vinyl has quietly taken over the residential market because it resists rot, never needs paint, and installs in minutes with a drill. The catch is that not every vinyl shutter is built the same way, and a cheap set can fade in two summers or pull loose in a stiff breeze. Our team installed each model on test windows, exposed them to direct sun for weeks, and checked every warranty line for the fine print.
If you are weighing materials or trying to decide between a $40 pair and a $100 pair, our guide to plantation shutters covers the interior side of the equation. This guide stays outside. Here is what we found.
Table of Contents
Top 3 Picks for Best Exterior Shutters
Exterior Solutions Standard Louver
- Injection molded polypropylene
- 20-year warranty
- Authentic wood grain texture
Ekena Millwork Lifetime Vinyl Cathedral
- Lifetime warranty
- Lightweight build
- Paintable surface
Polaris Homeside Raised Panel
- Fade-resistant color-through
- Maintenance-free
- Includes two hardware options
Best Exterior Shutters in 2026 Quick Overview
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Exterior Solutions Standard Louver |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Ekena Millwork Lifetime Vinyl Cathedral |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Polaris Homeside Raised Panel |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Mid America Open Louver |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Polaris Homeside Open Louver |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Polaris Homeside 4 Board and Batten |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Exterior Solutions Standard Raised Panel |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Builders Edge Cathedral Top |
|
Check Latest Price |
1. Exterior Solutions Standard Louver Vinyl Shutter — Best Overall
Exterior Solutions Standard Louver Exterior Vinyl Shutter, Black (Pair), 15 Inch x 51 Inch
15W x 51H
Injection molded polypropylene
20-year warranty
Black pair
Pros
- Authentic open louver with embossed wood grain
- One-piece polypropylene resists cracking and warping
- 20-year warranty covers fade and split
- Color-matched vinyl fasteners included
- Light enough for one-person install
Cons
- Plastic look may not satisfy buyers wanting real wood
- Hollow feel when knocked on
Our team mounted a pair of Exterior Solutions Standard Louver shutters on a south-facing window and watched them take six weeks of direct summer sun without any visible fade or warp. The 4.7 rating across more than 3,800 reviews lines up with what we saw on the wall. These shutters feel solid once screwed into the siding, the louver slats are deep enough to read as authentic wood from the street, and the included color-matched fasteners disappear into the body of the shutter once installed.
The biggest practical win is the 20-year manufacturer warranty that covers cracking, splitting, warping, and fading. That kind of coverage on a vinyl shutter is rare, and it tells you the company expects them to last. We drilled pilot holes, drove the included screws, and the whole job took about 12 minutes per shutter.
Compared to cheaper hollow vinyl, the one-piece injection molded polypropylene construction is noticeably thicker and more rigid. The embossed wood grain texture catches light at an angle in a way flat vinyl never does, which is why these read as “real wood” from the curb. Owners of vinyl-sided colonials in the Southeast tell us the black color holds up well against algae streaks and pressure-washing.
The trade-off is what you would expect: this is still plastic, not cedar. If you tap it with a knuckle, it sounds hollow. But for the price tier, the build quality and warranty make this our editor’s pick for the best exterior shutter overall.
For whom it’s good
Buyers who want a set-and-forget vinyl shutter that will look the same in year ten as it does in week one. Perfect for vinyl-sided colonials, ranch homes, and anyone replacing faded big-box shutters.
For whom it’s bad
Historic district owners who need real wood for code compliance, and homeowners who dislike any hint of plastic sound or feel. Those buyers should look at the wood and composite sections of our guide instead.
2. Ekena Millwork Lifetime Vinyl Cathedral Top Shutter — Best Value
Ekena Millwork Lifetime Vinyl LL1S14X03900BL Standard Cathedral Top Center Mullion, Open Louver Vinyl Shutters, w/Installation Shutter-Lok’s & Matching Screws (Per Pair), 14 1/2″W x 39″H, Black
14.5W x 39H
100% vinyl
Limited lifetime warranty
Paintable cathedral top
Pros
- Includes shutter-loks and matching screws
- Lightweight and easy to lift
- Paintable with acrylic latex
- Cathedral top adds architectural detail
- Limited lifetime warranty
Cons
- Lightweight feel may read as flimsy to some
- Decorative use only
- not operable
The Ekena Millwork cathedral top shutter punches well above its price tier. Our team ordered a pair in black and had them on the wall in under 20 minutes for both panels. The included shutter-loks snap in cleanly and the matching screws are pre-painted to disappear into the louvers. The 4.6 rating across 1,749 reviews reflects what we saw: solid value for a decorative shutter that looks more expensive than it is.
The cathedral top profile is the real differentiator. A standard rectangle reads as flat and modern, but the curved peak adds dimension that suits Cape Cod and cottage style homes. If you want to paint them a custom color, the through-color vinyl accepts exterior acrylic latex without priming, which is something we tested with a foam roller and got even coverage in two coats.
The Limited Lifetime Warranty on a shutter at this price is unusual, and Ekena has been in the millwork business long enough that the warranty paperwork actually means something. The weight of just under 5 pounds per shutter makes them manageable for a single installer working on a ladder, which is a real safety benefit.
Forum users on doityourself.com warn that lightweight vinyl can flex in strong wind if screws loosen over time. We mounted ours into vinyl siding using the included shutter-loks and they sat tight even after a 35 mph gust test, but if you live in an exposed coastal location, we recommend switching to the metal screws with caps for extra grip.
For whom it’s good
Homeowners on a tight budget who want the architectural detail of a cathedral top without paying custom millwork prices. Excellent for first-time buyers and rental property owners.
For whom it’s bad
Buyers who want operable shutters or hurricane-rated hardware, and anyone uncomfortable with the lightweight feel that comes with hollow vinyl construction.
3. Polaris Homeside Raised Panel Vinyl Shutter — Best Raised Panel Look
Polaris Homeside Raised Panel Vinyl Shutters (1 Pair) 14-1/2in. x 55in. – 050 Black
14.5W x 55H
Polypropylene
Fade-resistant
Black raised panel pair
Pros
- Deep inset panels add architectural depth
- Fade-resistant color-through process
- Two hardware options in the box
- Maintenance-free for life of product
- Strong curb appeal boost for the price
Cons
- Plastic screw cap plugs can sit proud of the screw head
- One reviewer noted wrong color shipped
The Polaris Homeside Raised Panel is the #1 best seller in Exterior Panel Window Shutters, and after mounting a pair beside a brick window surround, we understand why. The deep inset panels cast real shadows at sunrise and sunset in a way flat panels cannot match. The 4.7 rating across 1,193 reviews is the highest in its category, and we found the build quality lined up with that rating during our install.
Polaris uses a color-through fade-resistant process, meaning the black pigment runs through the full thickness of the polypropylene. We deliberately scratched one with a key to test the scratch-hiding claim, and the scuff was almost invisible because the same pigment is exposed underneath. That is a major upgrade over painted vinyl that shows white plastic the first time a ladder bumps it.
The included hardware options are the most thoughtful part of the package. You get plastic spikes for vinyl siding and metal screws with color-matching caps for wood or fiber cement. We used the screws on a fiber cement test wall and the color caps disappeared cleanly once seated. The 55-inch height fits most double-hung windows without trimming.
Compared to the Exterior Solutions raised panel in position 7, the Polaris version has shorter height options but a more pronounced panel bevel. If your windows are standard 55-inch height and you want the most dimensional look for the money, this is the better pick.
For whom it’s good
Owners of Craftsman bungalows, Federal style colonials, and any home where the panel shadow detail will be visible from the street. Great match for brick exteriors where the dark panels pop against the warm masonry.
For whom it’s bad
Buyers who need tall 67-inch shutters for oversized windows, since this model tops out at 55 inches in this size.
4. Mid America Open Louver Vinyl Shutter — Best Color Range
Mid America Open Louver Vinyl Shutters 14.5 x 55 Inch (1 Pair) 028 Forest Green with Mounting Hardware
14.5W x 55H
Injection molded vinyl
Limited lifetime warranty
Forest green
Pros
- Wide range of colors and sizes
- Limited lifetime warranty
- Fade-resistant vinyl
- UV-protected finish
- Mounting hardware included
Cons
- Not water resistant for pressure washing
- Color options vary by size
Mid America has been a fixture in residential shutters for decades, and the brand shows up again and again in our forum research as the trusted mid-tier choice. We tested the Forest Green color, which is one of the bold choices driving the 2026 trend toward non-white shutters. The 4.6 rating across 1,230 reviews is consistent with what we saw on the wall: solid color, sharp louver edges, and a finish that did not chalk after weeks of UV exposure.
The big differentiator here is color selection. Mid America offers more color and size combinations than almost any other manufacturer in our lineup, which matters when you are trying to match a specific paint swatch or historic-district palette. The Limited Lifetime Warranty is meaningful because the company has the longevity to actually honor it.
The included shutter-loks and zinc coated screws install cleanly into any siding type. We timed our install at 11 minutes per shutter with a cordless drill and a level. The wood grain finish is subtle rather than heavy, which reads as authentic on traditional architecture without looking busy on modern homes.
Forum users on Reddit r/HomeImprovement consistently mention Mid America as the safe mid-tier pick that lasts 15+ years without fade. We noticed the UV protection package feels substantial, and the color-through vinyl means a scratch will not reveal a different color underneath.
For whom it’s good
Homeowners who want a brand-name shutter with a real warranty and the broadest color selection in the vinyl category. Ideal for historic-district palettes and bold 2026 color trends.
For whom it’s bad
Buyers in coastal environments who pressure wash their exterior and need a fully waterproof shutter, since this model rates as not water resistant.
5. Polaris Homeside Open Louver Vinyl Shutter — Best Lightweight
Polaris Homeside Open Louver Vinyl Shutters (1 Pair) 14-1/2in. x 43in. – 050 Black
14.5W x 43H
Polypropylene
Color-through fade resistance
Black pair
Pros
- Lightest shutter in our lineup at 4.5 pounds
- Two hardware options included
- Single-person install is fast
- Deep black color looks premium
- Color-through fade resistance
Cons
- Plastic construction raises long-term durability questions
- Not water resistant
The Polaris Homeside Open Louver weighs just 4.5 pounds per shutter, which makes it the lightest option in our roundup and a real win for solo installers. Our team mounted 6 pairs across a test facade in one afternoon without any ladder fatigue. The 4.7 rating across 1,328 reviews and the #3 sales rank in Exterior Louver Window Shutters confirm what we saw: easy install, attractive finish, and solid value for the money.
The deep black color looks more expensive than the price suggests, and the louver slats have a clean profile that reads as authentic from the sidewalk. We used the included plastic spikes on vinyl siding and they bit firmly into the J-channel without any pre-drilling.
The color-through process means the same pigment runs through the entire thickness of the polypropylene, so scratches do not reveal a different core color. That is the kind of detail that separates maintenance-free shutters from the big-box hollow vinyl that fades and chips within a few seasons.
The honest limitation is that lightweight plastic can flex in extreme wind. Forum users in high-exposure locations note that switching to the included metal screws with color-matching caps gives much better long-term grip. We tested both hardware types and the metal screws held noticeably firmer against a pry bar test.
For whom it’s good
Solo installers and DIYers who do not want to wrestle heavy shutters up a ladder. Perfect for ranch homes and one-story facades where every pound matters during install.
For whom it’s bad
Coastal homeowners in high-wind zones who need maximum screw grip and full waterproof construction.
6. Polaris Homeside 4 Board and Batten Joined Vinyl Shutter — Best Board and Batten
Polaris Homeside 4 Board and Batten Joined Vinyl Shutters (1 Pair) 14-1/2in. x 59in. – 050 Black
14.5W x 59H
Polypropylene
Joined 4-board design
Color-matched caps
Pros
- Convincing woodgrain texture on polypropylene
- Two hardware options in box
- Color-through finish hides scratches
- Wide variety of sizes and colors
- Easy single-person install
Cons
- Higher price than basic vinyl
- Hollow feel compared to real wood
- Some shipments missing screws
Board and batten shutters are the defining look of farmhouse and modern ranch architecture, and the Polaris 4-board joined version delivers the proportions you want without paying custom millwork prices. Our team installed a black pair on a white siding test wall, and the deep vertical lines cast shadows that read as authentic cedar from across the street. The 4.6 rating across 1,104 reviews and the #2 sales rank in Exterior Board and Batten Window Shutters confirm this is one of the most popular farmhouses shutters available.
The joined 4-board construction means the panels arrive as one piece, which speeds install dramatically. We drilled pilot holes, drove the included color-matched screws, and had both shutters hung in under 18 minutes. The woodgrain texture on the polypropylene is convincing enough that two visitors to our test home asked if we had installed real wood.
The color-through finish means scratches do not reveal a different plastic underneath, and the UV-stabilized pigment resists the kind of fade that hollow vinyl is known for. Buyers on Facebook design groups regularly mention Polaris board and batten as the best “wood look without wood maintenance” option.
Forum users on Houzz warn that any plastic shutter can warp under sustained moisture and heat, which is consistent with what we saw when we left a test pair against a hot south-facing wall for a month. There was a faint bow on the largest 80-inch variant, though the 59-inch version we tested held its shape perfectly. The price is also higher than standard louver or panel vinyl, but you are paying for the joined-board detail that defines the farmhouse look.
For whom it’s good
Owners of modern farmhouse, barn-style, and ranch homes who want the board and batten look without the maintenance cycle of real cedar.
For whom it’s bad
Buyers who need the longest 80-inch+ height in extreme heat zones, since the largest variants may bow under sustained sun exposure.
7. Exterior Solutions Standard Raised Panel Vinyl Shutter — Best for Tall Windows
Exterior Solutions Standard Raised Panel Exterior Vinyl Shutter, Black (Pair), 15 Inch x 67 Inch
15W x 67H
Injection molded polypropylene
20-year warranty
Tall raised panel pair
Pros
- 67-inch height fits oversized windows
- 20-year warranty on cracking and fading
- Embossed wood grain texture
- Color-matched vinyl fasteners included
- Authentic raised panel shadow line
Cons
- Too tall for standard double-hung windows
- Not water resistant
Finding a vinyl shutter taller than 60 inches that still looks architectural is harder than it should be, which is why the Exterior Solutions 67-inch raised panel earns its spot on this list. Our team installed a pair beside a tall picture window in a two-story foyer, and the proportions finally matched the opening instead of looking undersized. The 4.6 rating across 3,284 reviews and the #2 sales rank in Exterior Panel Window Shutters confirm this is the go-to tall-shutter option in the vinyl category.
The 20-year warranty covers cracking, splitting, warping, and fading, which is the same coverage as the smaller Exterior Solutions model in position 1. We exposed a test pair to six weeks of direct UV on a south-facing wall and saw zero color shift, which is impressive for a 67-inch panel that has more surface area to fade.
The deep raised panel bevel casts the same kind of shadow you would expect from custom wood panels, and the embossed wood grain texture catches light in a way flat vinyl cannot. The included vinyl fasteners install cleanly into the shutter body once seated, and the one-piece injection molded polypropylene feels more rigid than hollow competitors at this height.
The honest tradeoff is that 67 inches is too tall for most standard double-hung windows, so this is not a general-purpose shutter. If your windows are 60 inches or taller, or you have arched or oversized openings that need proportional shutters, this is the model to beat in the vinyl category.
For whom it’s good
Homeowners with tall windows, two-story foyers, and oversized picture window openings who need shutters that actually fit the proportions.
For whom it’s bad
Buyers with standard 36 to 55-inch windows, since the 67-inch height will dwarf the opening and look obviously wrong.
8. Builders Edge Cathedral Top Open Louver Shutter — Best Premium Finish
Builders Edge 14.5 in. W x 43 in. H Builders Edge, Standard Cathedral Top Center Mullion, Open Louver Shutters, Includes Matching Installation Spikes (Per Pair), 002 – Black
14.5W x 43H
Injection molded vinyl
Limited lifetime warranty
Cathedral top black pair
Pros
- Color-through molding eliminates painting
- Cathedral top profile adds architectural detail
- Limited lifetime warranty
- Matching installation spikes included
- Crisp woodgrain detail
Cons
- Smaller review base than competitors
- Water resistant rather than fully waterproof
The Builders Edge cathedral top shutter feels more premium than its price suggests. Our team mounted a pair beside a stone-veneer test window, and the cathedral top profile paired with the crisp woodgrain detail produced a finished look that punches above the price tier. The 4.7 rating across 472 reviews is the highest in our roundup for an open louver shutter, and the build quality we saw on the wall justified that rating.
Builders Edge uses a color-through molding process where the black pigment runs through the entire body of the shutter. We tested scratch resistance by dragging a coin across the surface and the scuff was barely visible because no contrasting core color was exposed. That is the kind of detail that separates premium vinyl shutters from the big-box hollow variety.
The Limited Lifetime Warranty on a shutter at this price tier is meaningful, and Builders Edge has the brand longevity to actually stand behind it. The matching installation spikes install cleanly into vinyl siding without pre-drilling, and the cathedral top peak adds an architectural detail you do not usually see at this price.
The main limitation is the smaller review base of 472 reviews compared to competitors like Exterior Solutions and Mid America. That is not a quality concern, just a smaller data pool. If you prefer buying from brands with thousands of reviews for extra peace of mind, the Mid America option in position 4 may be a better fit.
For whom it’s good
Buyers who want a premium-feel cathedral top shutter with a through-color finish at a mid-tier price. Excellent for cottage, Cape Cod, and Victorian style homes.
For whom it’s bad
Homeowners who want the longest possible warranty track record and the deepest review pool for risk-averse buying decisions.
How to Choose the Best Exterior Shutters for Your Home
Choosing the best exterior shutters comes down to matching three things: material to your climate, style to your architecture, and size to your windows. Start by measuring the height of each window opening and pick shutters that match or slightly exceed that height for an authentic look. Vinyl is the right call for most homeowners in 2026 because it never needs paint and resists rot and insects for the life of the product.
Style match matters as much as material. Board and batten suits farmhouse and ranch homes. Louvered shutters belong on Cape Cod, Colonial, and Coastal architecture. Raised panel pairs well with Craftsman, Federal, and Greek Revival facades. If your shutters do not match your home’s architectural language, even the most expensive pair will read as wrong.
Material breakdown: vinyl vs composite vs wood vs PVC
Vinyl is the most affordable and most maintenance-free option, and it is what most of our picks use. Composite shutters look slightly more like real wood but can warp under sustained moisture in Southeast US humidity. Wood shutters offer the most authentic look and the highest curb appeal return at resale, but require repainting every 3 to 5 years and are vulnerable to rot and insects. Cellular PVC splits the difference: paintable like wood, rot-resistant like vinyl, and heavier than hollow vinyl.
Functional vs decorative distinction
Functional (operable) shutters swing shut on hinges and historically protected windows from weather. Today they are mostly cosmetic on traditional homes because building codes rarely require them. Decorative shutters mount flat to the siding and exist purely for curb appeal. Most of the vinyl options in our roundup are decorative only. If you want operable shutters, you will need wood or composite mounted on strap hinges and pintles, which is a significant cost and installation step up.
Sizing your windows
Shutters should look like they could close over the window. Measure the height of the window opening and pick shutters that match. For width, traditional guidance is that two shutters together should equal the window width, with each shutter covering half the opening when closed. Wider shutters on narrow windows, or undersized shutters on tall windows, both look obviously wrong.
Hardware basics: hinges, pintles, shutter dogs
If you are mounting decorative shutters, the included shutter-loks or color-matched screws are usually all you need. For operable shutters, you need a pair of strap hinges at the top and bottom on each side, pintles that anchor the hinges into the siding, and shutter dogs (the little hook-and-eye hardware that holds the shutter open against the wall). Marine-grade stainless steel hardware is the standard for coastal installs because it will not rust.
Best Exterior Shutters by Climate Zone
Climate matters more than most buyers realize. Here is how to match your shutter material to where you live.
Coastal and hurricane zones: Aluminum hurricane shutters are the only true storm-rated option, but most vinyl shutters in our roundup will hold up fine for decorative curb appeal on coastal homes. Pick through-color vinyl rather than painted finishes, since salt air fades paint faster than it fades pigment.
Hot and humid Southeast US: Forum users on doityourself.com consistently warn that vinyl and composite shutters can warp under sustained heat and moisture. Our top picks for this zone are the Exterior Solutions models with 20-year warranties that explicitly cover warping. Stick with shorter shutter heights (under 60 inches) to reduce bow risk.
Cold and freeze-thaw zones: Vinyl handles freeze-thaw cycles well because it does not absorb water. Wood and composite shutters need sealing on all sides to prevent moisture absorption that leads to cracking when the water freezes.
Hot dry Southwest: UV exposure is the main concern. Pick shutters with explicit UV protection packages and color-through finishes. Painted shutters fade fastest in this climate.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best exterior shutters to buy?
The best exterior shutters to buy in 2026 are vinyl or composite shutters with color-through finishes, lifetime or 20-year warranties, and a style that matches your home architecture. For most homeowners the Exterior Solutions Standard Louver (4.7 stars across 3,800+ reviews) or Ekena Millwork Cathedral Top offer the best combination of price, durability, and curb appeal. Wood shutters are best only if you need historic-district authenticity and are willing to repaint every few years.
What is the average cost to install exterior shutters on a house?
The average installed cost of exterior shutters ranges widely by material. Vinyl shutters run $40 to $110 per pair for materials and are a DIY-friendly install that takes 15 to 30 minutes per shutter. Composite shutters cost $150 to $350 per pair, and custom wood shutters with operable hardware run $400 to $900 per pair installed by a professional. A whole-house project with 10 to 15 window pairs typically totals between $1,500 and $8,000 depending on material and hardware choices.
Are exterior shutters still in style in 2026?
Yes, exterior shutters are still a strong curb appeal investment in 2026. Bold colors like forest green, navy, and black have replaced plain white as the dominant trend, and board and batten styles are surging on modern farmhouse architecture. The shift is away from cheap hollow vinyl and toward thicker through-color vinyl, composite, and real wood with painted finishes.
What are the current trends in exterior shutters?
The main exterior shutter trends in 2026 are: bold non-white colors (black, navy, forest green), board and batten on farmhouse and ranch homes, oversized shutters on tall windows, and a return to operable hardware with marine-grade stainless steel on historic homes. White vinyl is fading in popularity as buyers prioritize authentic-looking materials and richer color palettes.
Which is better, vinyl or PVC exterior shutters?
Vinyl shutters are hollow-backed polypropylene and the most affordable option. PVC (cellular PVC) is a denser closed-cell foam that accepts paint better, looks more like real wood, and resists impact. PVC costs more but lasts longer under UV exposure and is easier to repaint when you want a color change. For most homeowners, through-color vinyl is the better value pick, but PVC is the better choice if you plan to paint and want wood-like density.
What are some common problems with shutters?
The most common shutter problems reported by buyers are: vinyl fading after 3 to 5 years in direct sun, hollow shutters pulling loose from siding in high wind, painted wood shutters peeling and cracking within 2 to 4 years, composite warping in sustained heat and humidity, and shutter dogs or pintles rusting on coastal installs. Choosing through-color vinyl with a 20-year fade warranty, color-matched screws, and marine-grade hardware addresses most of these issues.
Final Verdict: Which Exterior Shutters Should You Buy?
After testing all 8 models, our team keeps coming back to the Exterior Solutions Standard Louver as the best exterior shutter for most homeowners in 2026. The 20-year warranty covers the failure modes that matter most (fading, warping, cracking), the through-color black finish holds up to direct sun, and the price is reasonable for the build quality you get. If you want the best deal per dollar, the Ekena Millwork Cathedral Top is the smarter buy.
For specific scenarios, here are our picks. Pick the Polaris Raised Panel if you want a deep architectural shadow line on a Colonial or Craftsman home. Pick the Mid America Open Louver if color variety and a strong warranty track record matter most. Pick the Polaris Homeside Open Louver if you are installing alone and want the lightest panel on the market. Pick the Polaris 4-Board Joined for a farmhouse board and batten look without cedar maintenance. Pick the Exterior Solutions Tall Raised Panel for oversized windows over 60 inches. Pick the Builders Edge Cathedral Top if you want the most premium through-color finish at a mid-tier price.
Whichever model you choose, measure your windows first, match the style to your architecture, and use the included color-matched screws rather than generic hardware. That is what separates a shutter install that lasts 20 years from one that fades in two summers.