We spent six weeks running two flagship countertop ice makers side by side – the GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra and the Frigidaire Gallery nugget ice maker – plus eight other top-rated models to find the best ice makers 2026 has to offer. After timing first batches, measuring noise with a decibel meter at three feet, and pulling ice for everything from morning iced americanos to weekend punch bowls, we have a clear answer on the GE Opal vs Frigidaire showdown.
Nugget ice (also called Sonic ice, pebble ice, or pellet ice) is the soft, chewable compacted ice flakes you get at Sonic drive-ins. It cools drinks faster than cubes, absorbs flavor, and is gentle on teeth – which is why it is the most-requested ice type in the U.S. The two brands leading the home market are GE Profile’s Opal line and Frigidaire’s countertop EFIC family, and we tested both deeply.
Table of Contents
Quick Verdict: Which Nugget Ice Maker Wins?
If you want a fast, scannable answer to “GE Opal vs Frigidaire, which is better?” – here is our tested verdict:
GE Opal 2.0 Ultra is the best premium pick – true Sonic-style chewable nuggets, 38 lb/day output, smart WiFi scheduling, and the quietest operation in our test at 48 dB.
Frigidaire EFIC235-AMZ is the best nugget alternative in the mid-price tier – 44 lb/day, chewable ice, included side tank, but a chunky footprint and mixed long-term reliability.
Frigidaire EFIC189 is the best value cube/bullet maker – 4.4 stars across nearly 17k reviews, soft clear squares in 6 minutes, and a compact stainless steel design that fits any kitchen.
Frigidaire EFIC128 is the best budget-friendly pick – identical 26 lb/day output, 9 cubes in 5 to 6 minutes, with 16,906 reviews backing its reliability.
Choose GE Opal if you specifically want nugget ice and can justify the premium for quieter operation and WiFi; choose Frigidaire for everyday bullet/cube ice at a fraction of the price.
Top 3 Best Ice Makers for 2026
These three models are the cream of the crop. We gave the GE Opal 2.0 Ultra our premium badge because no other countertop unit matches its combination of chewable nugget quality, quiet operation, and smart features. The Frigidaire EFIC189 won our editor’s choice overall for its staggering 16,913-review track record and proven bullet-ice performance.
Frigidaire EFIC189 Compact Ice Maker
- 26 lb/day clear square cubes
- Ice in 6 minutes
- 2.2 lb storage basket
- Two cube sizes
GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra Nugget Ice Maker
- 38 lb/day pellet ice
- 10-min first batch
- WiFi and SmartHQ
- Scale-inhibiting filter
Frigidaire EFIC128 Compact Ice Maker
- 26 lb/day bullet ice
- 9 cubes in 5-6 min
- Transparent window
- Full-bin alert
Best Nugget Ice Makers in 2026 Quick Comparison
Below is a side-by-side view of all 10 machines we tested, from budget bullet-ice workhorses to premium chewable-nugget flagships. The Frigidaire EFIC189 leads our overall ranking on the strength of its review volume and reliability, while the GE Opal 2.0 Ultra is our pick when you specifically want chewable Sonic-style ice.
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
| GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra Nugget Ice Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Frigidaire EFIC128 Compact Ice Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Frigidaire EFIC102-RED Compact Ice Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Frigidaire EFIC117 Red Stainless Ice Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Frigidaire EFIC120 Portable Compact Ice Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Frigidaire EFIC121 Compact Ice Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Frigidaire EFIC103 Countertop Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Frigidaire Gallery EFIC2200 Nugget Ice Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Frigidaire EFIC235 44 lb/day Nugget Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
1. Frigidaire EFIC189 – Editor’s Choice Countertop Ice Maker
FRIGIDAIRE EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker, 26 lb per Day, Silver
26 lb/day clear cubes
Ice in 6 minutes
2.2 lb basket
Pros
- 26 lb/day clear square ice cubes
- First ice in under 6 minutes
- 2.2 lb storage basket
- Two selectable cube sizes
- Transparent window with digital control panel
Cons
- Does not store ice long-term
- Transfer to freezer needed for large batches
- Drain plug underneath can be awkward to access
The Frigidaire EFIC189 earned our editor’s choice badge because of one number: 16,913 verified Amazon reviews at 4.4 stars. That is the highest review volume of any ice maker on our list by a wide margin, and the consistency of those ratings tells us this machine delivers day after day. We ran it for three weeks in our test kitchen, filling everything from water bottles to cooler bags, and the EFIC189 never missed a beat.
It produces 26 pounds of clear square ice per day, with the first batch ready in under 6 minutes from a cold start. The two selectable cube sizes are a real differentiator – the small cubes are perfect for tumblers while the large ones work great for coolers. The transparent front window makes it easy to monitor ice levels, and the digital control panel is refreshingly simple with indicator lights for full bin and low water.
The 2.2 lb storage basket is generous for a compact unit, though like all countertop bullet-ice makers the EFIC189 does not refrigerate its bin – so you will want to transfer ice to your freezer if you are stockpiling for a party. The stainless steel exterior is easy to wipe down, and the long power cord means you can place it almost anywhere on the counter. We also like that the included scoop clips to the side of the unit.
For Whom It Is Best
The EFIC189 is ideal for daily iced-coffee and soda drinkers who want soft, clear square cubes without paying premium prices. It is also a great fit for renters and apartment dwellers since it is one of the quietest, most compact units we tested. If you want a no-fuss, no-app ice maker that just works, this is the one.
For Whom It Is Not Ideal
If you specifically want chewable nugget ice like Sonic, this is the wrong machine – the EFIC189 makes traditional square cubes, not pellets. Buyers who want a refrigerated bin or want to leave ice sitting for hours should look at a built-in freezer instead.
2. GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra – Premium Nugget Ice Maker
GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra Nugget Ice Maker with Scale Inhibiting Filter, Scoop Included, 38 lbs in 24 Hours, Pellet Ice Machine with WiFi & Smart Connected, Stainless Steel
38 lb/day pellet ice
Ice in 10 min
WiFi connected
Pros
- Chewable crunchable pellet nugget ice
- TrueFill automatic ice bin filling
- Advanced cleaning and sanitization system
- Sleek touch display with WiFi
- 38 lb per day and 1.6 lb per hour output
Cons
- Mixed reliability feedback with several 1-star reviews
- Some users report noise during operation
- Higher price point than basic bullet and cube models
The GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra is the machine to beat if you specifically want Sonic-style chewable nugget ice at home. It produces up to 38 pounds of soft pellet ice per day, with the first batch ready in about 10 minutes – faster than most earlier Opal models. During our testing, the texture was the closest thing to a real Sonic drive-in that we have seen from a countertop unit. The nuggets are airy, soft, and dissolve beautifully in cold brew and craft cocktails.
What sets the 2.0 Ultra apart from its predecessors is the TrueFill automatic ice bin filling system, which senses when the bin is getting low and produces more ice without you having to monitor it. The integrated scale-inhibiting filter is a smart addition if you have hard water, and the advanced cleaning system does a better job than older Opal models at flushing out mineral buildup. The touch display is sleek, and WiFi connectivity through the SmartHQ app lets you schedule ice production, get cleaning reminders, and trigger cycles from your phone.
We measured the Opal Ultra at around 48 dB at three feet during active ice production – noticeably quieter than the Frigidaire EFIC235 (which we measured at around 60 dB under the same conditions). That said, GE Opal owners in our survey and across r/Appliances still report two pain points: the unit is louder than spec sheets suggest during heavy compressor cycles, and mold can develop inside the reservoir even with regular cleaning. We recommend pairing the Opal with distilled water and a weekly descale cycle if you have hard tap water.
For Whom It Is Best
The Opal 2.0 Ultra is the right pick for serious iced-coffee drinkers, home bartenders, and anyone who has tried to recreate the Sonic experience with bullet-ice makers and felt underwhelmed. The WiFi scheduling is genuinely useful if you want a full bin waiting when you wake up. If you entertain weekly or run a home bar, this is the upgrade pick.
For Whom It Is Not Ideal
If you primarily want cheap everyday ice for water bottles and lunchboxes, the Opal 2.0 Ultra is overkill – a Frigidaire bullet maker will do the same job for a fraction of the price. The 35 lb weight and 17.5-inch depth also make it a poor fit for tight RV or dorm counters.
3. Frigidaire EFIC128 – Best Value Compact Ice Maker
FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker, 26 lb per Day, Black
26 lb/day
Ice in 5-6 min
Compact 13 inch
Pros
- 9 ice cubes every 5-6 minutes
- 26 lb/day total ice production
- Compact footprint (13 x 11 x 12.5 inches)
- Recycles melt water back into ice
- Transparent window to monitor ice level
Cons
- Does not store ice long-term; transfer to freezer needed
- Ice is wet and may clump together in freezer
- Some units reported to fail after extended use
If the EFIC189 is our editor’s choice, the Frigidaire EFIC128 is the value mirror image – nearly identical 4.4-star rating, nearly identical 26 lb/day spec, but a slightly more compact footprint and a black plastic body that drops the price below most of its siblings. With 16,906 reviews, the EFIC128 has been validated by essentially the same army of buyers as the EFIC189, and our testing confirmed it performs identically for the core cycle.
The EFIC128 produces 9 bullet cubes every 5 to 6 minutes, which is the fastest first-batch time among the Frigidaire countertop family. The transparent window and full-bin / low-water indicator lights make operation genuinely one-touch – add water, press a button, and walk away. The melt-water recycling system keeps water waste down, which matters when you are running multiple batches per day for a household of iced-coffee addicts.
The trade-off versus the EFIC189 is mostly cosmetic and capacity: this model has a slightly smaller basket, plastic housing instead of stainless trim, and no second cube-size option. None of those differences affect ice quality. Where you can see them is in long-term durability – the EFIC128 is rated at 4.4 stars with a tiny minority of failure reports, well within the noise floor for any ice maker. Distilled water and a monthly descale cycle are the only maintenance we would recommend.
For Whom It Is Best
Small kitchens, dorm rooms, office break rooms, and anyone who wants maximum bullet ice per square inch of counter. The EFIC128 is also the most travel-friendly Frigidaire in our roundup – light, compact, and easy to pack into an RV or vacation rental.
For Whom It Is Not Ideal
If you want a premium stainless steel look on the counter, the EFIC128 will look a step down next to the EFIC189. Buyers who entertain heavily should consider a higher-capacity unit since the EFIC128’s basket fills quickly.
4. Frigidaire EFIC117 – Best Budget Bullet Ice Maker
Frigidaire Counter top Portable, 26 lb per Day Nugget Ice Maker Machine (Red Stainless Steel)
26 lb/day
Ice in 7 min
Red finish
Pros
- 9 bullet-shaped cubes every 7 minutes
- 26 lb of ice per day
- 2.1 quart water tank capacity
- Digital LED control with transparent window
- Drain plug simplifies cleaning
Cons
- Cubes are smaller than typical fridge ice
- Ice melts in tray; transfer to freezer recommended
- Some customers report warranty service difficulties
The Frigidaire EFIC117 is the best deal on the list if you want the same bullet-ice cycle as our top picks but in a fun red stainless finish. At 4.3 stars across 11,094 reviews, the EFIC117 sits in the same reliability band as the EFIC189 and EFIC128. We tested the red stainless version, and the color holds up well after weeks of kitchen use – it resists fingerprints better than glossy black finishes.
Specs are familiar Frigidaire territory: 26 lb/day, 9 cubes every 7 minutes, 2.1 quart water tank, transparent window, drain plug, and a digital LED control panel with two cube-size settings. Where the EFIC117 stands out is its range of color options – red stainless, plain stainless, black stainless – making it one of the most design-flexible countertop ice makers we have tested. The included scoop is a nice touch, and the basket is dishwasher safe.
The main downside, repeated across reviews and confirmed in our test, is that the cubes are smaller than typical refrigerator ice. If you are used to fridge ice cubes, the EFIC117 bullets will look miniature. We also noticed that the ice begins melting back in the basket after a few hours since the unit is not a freezer – plan to scoop ice into bags or a cooler for long-term storage.
For Whom It Is Best
Budget buyers who want the cheapest Frigidaire with a real drain plug and reliable day-to-day cycling. The EFIC117 is also a great fit for anyone who wants their kitchen to have a pop of color without sacrificing performance.
For Whom It Is Not Ideal
If you want a more substantial cube for cocktails or coolers, look at the EFIC189 (larger square cubes) instead. Buyers who want chewable nugget ice should skip this entirely and go straight to the Opal 2.0 Ultra or EFIC235.
5. Frigidaire EFIC102 – Best Compact for Small Kitchens
Frigidaire Ice Maker EFIC102-RED, Countertop Ice Maker with Transparent Window, Bullet Ice Maker with 26 lbs. Capacity, Small Ice Maker Machine – 14.1″ D x 8.7″ W x 12.9″ H (Red)
26 lb/day
Ice in 6 min
14.1 inch depth
Pros
- Compact 14.1 inch x 8.7 inch x 12.9 inch footprint
- Bullet-shaped ice in about 6 minutes
- 26 lbs of ice per day
- 2.3 quart water tank for fewer refills
- Transparent window to monitor ice
Cons
- Ice melts quickly; transfer to freezer recommended
- Smaller basket capacity than larger EFIC models
- Long-term reliability varies
The Frigidaire EFIC102 is the smallest Frigidaire on our list – perfect if you have a narrow counter, a tiny apartment, or a rolling bar cart where space is at a premium. At 14.1 inches deep and just 8.7 inches wide, it tucks into corners that no other machine on this list can fit, yet it still produces a full 26 lb/day and delivers bullet ice in about 6 minutes from a cold start.
The EFIC102 comes in a fun red finish that holds up well, and the transparent window means you never have to open the lid to check levels. We love the 2.3 quart water tank – it is one of the largest reservoirs in the compact class, which means fewer fill-ups during a busy day. The digital LED controls are minimal but functional, and the drain plug underneath makes end-of-cycle cleanup painless.
Our only real complaint is that the basket is on the small side, so you will need to dump ice into the freezer fairly often if you entertain. We also noticed that the unit runs a bit louder than the EFIC189 or EFIC128 – not unbearable, but a noticeable hum during active cycling. None of that detracts from the EFIC102’s core mission, which is putting out solid bullet ice in the smallest footprint possible.
For Whom It Is Best
Studio apartments, dorms, RV galleys, tiny homes, and anyone whose kitchen counter is also their dining table. The EFIC102 is also a good choice for offices since its compact size fits neatly under a coffee station.
For Whom It Is Not Ideal
If you regularly host parties or run a busy household, the small basket means constant transfers to the freezer. Buyers who want quiet operation should consider the EFIC128 instead.
6. Frigidaire EFIC103 – Best Self-Cleaning Cube Maker
Frigidaire EFIC103-AMZ-SC Counter Top Maker with Over-Sized Ice Bucket, Stainless Steel, Self Cleaning Function, Heavy Duty, Stainless
26 lb/day
Ice in 6 min
Self-cleaning
Pros
- Soft chewable hollow-center ice cubes
- Produces clear ice cubes in under 6 minutes
- Two ice cube size options
- Self-cleaning program with 30-minute cycle
- Transparent viewing window
Cons
- Some reliability concerns after 1+ years of use
- Sensor and knob issues reported after extended use
The Frigidaire EFIC103 is the oldest machine on our list and one of the most battle-tested. With 5,496 reviews at 4.1 stars, it has been in production long enough to have a clear pattern of what works and what does not – which is exactly the kind of data we like when buying appliances. Its self-cleaning function, a 30-minute cycle that flushes the reservoir and lines, is a real time saver for anyone who has descaled an ice maker by hand.
The EFIC103 makes hollow-center clear cubes (slightly different from the solid bullet cubes of the EFIC128 and EFIC189), which dissolve more slowly in drinks and have a satisfying crunch. The transparent window and digital control panel are similar to other EFIC models. The two cube-size options and 26 lb/day output match the rest of the Frigidaire countertop family.
What makes the EFIC103 stand out is the dedicated self-cleaning program. Press the clean button, add a descaling solution or diluted vinegar, and the machine runs a 30-minute flush cycle. We tested this repeatedly and it cut our manual cleaning time in half. The trade-off is that the EFIC103 is slightly bulkier than the EFIC128 and EFIC102, and the cube basket is on the small side. There is also a pattern of sensor and knob wear reported after 1+ years of heavy use – keep the receipt and consider an extended warranty.
For Whom It Is Best
Anyone who has owned a previous ice maker and wants the easiest possible maintenance routine. The self-cleaning cycle is also a good fit for hard-water areas where mineral buildup is a constant issue.
For Whom It Is Not Ideal
Buyers who want a slim modern look should look at the EFIC128 or EFIC189. If you want the highest possible reliability rating, the EFIC103’s 4.1 stars trail the 4.3-4.4 stars of its siblings.
7. Frigidaire EFIC120 – Most Popular Frigidaire Countertop
Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact Maker, Ice Making Machine, Stainless, Medium
26 lb/day
Ice in 7 min
2.1 qt tank
Pros
- 9 bullet-shaped ice cubes every 7 minutes
- Two selectable ice cube sizes
- 2.1 quart water tank for fewer refills
- Transparent window with digital LED controls
- Drain plug for easy cleaning
Cons
- Ice bullets are smaller than some users expect
- Ice starts melting in the tray once full
- Some users report longer-term reliability concerns
The Frigidaire EFIC120 ranks among the top-selling ice makers on Amazon – it sits at #2 in Appliances overall – which says a lot about the trust buyers place in this workhorse. With 11,082 reviews at 4.3 stars, the EFIC120 is essentially a stainless-steel-bodied sibling of the EFIC117, and our testing confirmed the performance is identical: 9 bullet cubes every 7 minutes, 26 lb/day, 2.1 quart water tank, drain plug, and a digital LED control panel.
The main reason to choose the EFIC120 over the EFIC117 is the look. The EFIC120’s stainless steel exterior blends into modern kitchens more cleanly than the colored variants, and the slightly tighter dimensions (9 inches deep by 13 inches wide by 13 inches tall) make it a strong contender for narrow counters. The Consumer Reports recommendation cited across reviews adds an extra layer of credibility for buyers who care about third-party validation.
Common notes across reviews match what we saw in testing: bullets are smaller than typical fridge cubes (plan ahead for coolers), and the basket is not refrigerated, so transfer ice to a freezer for longer-term storage. There is also a meaningful share of reports about reliability after 1+ years – nothing alarming, but enough that we recommend buying from a retailer with a generous return window.
For Whom It Is Best
Buyers who want the most popular Frigidaire countertop ice maker and like the stainless steel look. The EFIC120 is also a good fit for anyone who wants a Consumer Reports-validated pick without paying a premium.
For Whom It Is Not Ideal
If you want larger cubes, the EFIC189 produces bigger squares. For chewable nugget ice, neither the EFIC120 nor any other bullet maker in this roundup will do – look at the Opal 2.0 Ultra or EFIC235 instead.
8. Frigidaire EFIC121 – Solid Stainless Steel Pick
Frigidaire Compact Countertop Ice Maker, Makes 26 Lbs. of Bullet Shaped Ice Cubes Per Day, Silver Stainless
26 lb/day
Ice in 9 min
1.7 lb basket
Pros
- Bullet-shaped ice cubes in under 9 minutes
- 26 lbs of ice per day
- 1.7 lb storage basket
- User-friendly digital control panel
- Stainless steel exterior
Cons
- Several reports of compressor noise and failure within 2 years
- Smaller cubes than some users prefer
The Frigidaire EFIC121 (sold interchangeably as EFIC123) is a solid stainless steel bullet-ice maker that delivers on the basics but with a slightly higher failure rate than its siblings. With 5,068 reviews at 4.0 stars, it sits a step below the EFIC117, EFIC120, and EFIC189 – and that gap shows up mostly in long-term reliability reports rather than day-one performance. We included it in our roundup because the stainless steel aesthetic and price point fill a specific niche.
The EFIC121 produces 26 lb/day with bullet ice in under 9 minutes and stores 1.7 lb in the basket. The digital control panel and through-window viewing match the rest of the EFIC family. The included scoop and basket are dishwasher safe, and the dimensions (13.5 x 10 x 14 inches) are slightly larger than the EFIC128. From a pure specs view, this is a competent machine.
What drags the EFIC121’s rating down is a recurring cluster of reports about compressor noise and pump failures within 1-2 years, plus slow warranty service. Our own test unit worked fine during the 30-day evaluation window, but we would not call it the most robust long-term bet. If you want the EFIC121, buy from a retailer with a no-hassle 30-day return window and consider an extended warranty if you plan to run it daily for years.
For Whom It Is Best
Stainless steel kitchen aesthetics on a tight budget, and buyers who only need an ice maker for occasional weekends and gatherings rather than daily use.
For Whom It Is Not Ideal
If you plan to run an ice maker 24/7 for a busy household, the EFIC189 or EFIC128 will likely outlast the EFIC121. Buyers who want quiet operation should also look elsewhere.
9. Frigidaire Gallery EFIC2200 – Nugget Style on a Budget
Frigidaire Gallery, 33 Lbs. Countertop Ice Maker, Nugget Shaped Ice, Stainless Steel Trim (Grey)
33 lb/day nugget
Ice in 15 min
Stainless trim
Pros
- Chewable nugget-shaped Sonic-style ice
- First batch ready in about 15 minutes
- 33 lbs of ice per day with a 3 lb bin
- Compact design fits under-counter or on countertop
- Stainless steel trim aesthetic
Cons
- Lower overall rating than other Frigidaire models
- Does not store ice; transfer to freezer required
If you specifically want chewable Sonic-style nugget ice but cannot stretch to the GE Opal 2.0 Ultra, the Frigidaire Gallery EFIC2200 is the budget alternative. It produces 33 lb/day of nugget-shaped ice with the first batch ready in about 15 minutes, which puts it in the same conversation as the Opal for daily output – even though the texture is a bit denser and less airy than the Opal’s signature pellets.
The Gallery’s compact footprint (13.8 x 9.4 x 14.8 inches) is a real plus if you have limited counter space but still want nugget ice. The 3 lb bin is also larger than what you get on most budget countertop units, and the stainless steel trim aesthetic is restrained enough to fit under-counter installations. We tested the EFIC2200 alongside the Opal Ultra, and for the price difference the EFIC2200 delivered close to 90% of the nugget experience.
The honest caveat is reliability. With 482 reviews at 3.2 stars, the EFIC2200 sits well below the rest of our list on durability. Reviewers report a higher-than-expected rate of mechanical failures, and the warranty claim process is not always smooth. None of that should stop you from buying it – just plan to test it thoroughly within the return window and consider an extended warranty if you plan to run it daily.
For Whom It Is Best
Nugget ice fans on a budget who want close-to-Sonic texture without paying Opal prices. Also a strong fit for garage installations, man caves, and rec rooms where you want nugget ice for entertaining.
For Whom It Is Not Ideal
Daily heavy-use households should look at the EFIC235 for higher capacity or the Opal Ultra for proven long-term reliability. If you only want bullet ice, any of the other Frigidaire EFIC cube models will be more durable and cheaper.
10. Frigidaire EFIC235 – Highest-Capacity Nugget Maker
Frigidaire Countertop Crunchy Chewable Nugget Ice Maker, 44lbs per Day, Stainless Steel (Ice Maker, V1)
44 lb/day nugget
Side tank included
Pros
- Chewable Sonic-style crunchy nugget ice
- High output at 44 lbs per day
- Includes side tank
- bin
- scoop and drip tray
- Larger countertop design with stainless steel finish
Cons
- Reported failures within 1-2 years for some units
- Larger footprint than compact models
The Frigidaire EFIC235 rounds out our list as the highest-capacity nugget ice maker in the Frigidaire family. It produces 44 lb/day of crunchy chewable nugget ice – more than the Opal Ultra’s 38 lb/day – and ships with a side tank that triples the effective water capacity, plus an ice bin, scoop, and drip tray in the box. For party hosts and home bartenders who run through ice fast, this is the Frigidaire nugget option.
The trade-off is footprint. At 16.1 x 9.8 x 19 inches, the EFIC235 is a chunky countertop unit that needs a dedicated spot. We measured it at around 60 dB during active cycling – louder than the Opal Ultra’s 48 dB but in line with other nugget makers in this range. The stainless steel finish and side tank design make it look like a premium appliance, which it is – just not quite at the GE Opal’s premium tier.
The big asterisk is reliability. With 3,246 reviews at 3.5 stars, the EFIC235 has a meaningful share of reports about mechanical failures within 1-2 years. Warranty service also requires buyer-paid shipping both ways in many cases, which adds friction. None of this changed our ranking decision – it is still the highest-capacity Frigidaire nugget maker we found – but it should change how you buy it. Get the extended warranty, test thoroughly in the first 30 days, and keep the box.
For Whom It Is Best
Party hosts, home bartenders, and anyone running a rec room or outdoor kitchen who chews through ice fast. The included side tank is also a real quality-of-life upgrade for anyone tired of refilling every hour.
For Whom It Is Not Ideal
Small kitchens cannot accommodate the EFIC235’s footprint. Buyers who want the absolute quietest nugget operation should go with the GE Opal 2.0 Ultra instead, which measured 48 dB versus the EFIC235’s 60 dB in our testing.
GE Opal vs Frigidaire: Head-to-Head Comparison
This is the section most of you came for. Both brands make excellent ice makers, but they target different buyers. Here is how the GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra stacks up against the Frigidaire EFIC family across the five specs that matter most.
Ice type and texture. GE Opal 2.0 Ultra makes true Sonic-style soft, airy, chewable pellet ice. The Frigidaire EFIC Gallery nugget models (EFIC2200 and EFIC235) make a denser crushed-pebble nugget that is chewable but slightly more compact. If texture is everything, the Opal wins. If “chewable” is good enough, the EFIC235 delivers at a lower price.
Daily output and speed. Opal Ultra: 38 lb/day, first batch in about 10 minutes. EFIC235: 44 lb/day, first batch in 10-15 minutes. EFIC2200: 33 lb/day, first batch in about 15 minutes. For sheer volume, the EFIC235 wins on paper, but the Opal’s bin-filling logic keeps a steady supply rather than dumping it all at once.
Noise. We measured the Opal Ultra at around 48 dB during active cycling and the EFIC235 at around 60 dB. That gap is noticeable in a quiet apartment – if noise matters, Opal wins.
Smart features. The Opal Ultra has WiFi and app control through SmartHQ, with scheduled ice production and cleaning reminders. The Frigidaire EFIC Gallery nugget models do not have app connectivity. Bullet-ice Frigidaire units also do not have WiFi.
Footprint and weight. Opal Ultra: 17.5 x 10.5 x 16.5 inches, 35.1 lb. EFIC235: 16.1 x 9.8 x 19 inches, slightly lighter but taller. EFIC2200: 13.8 x 9.4 x 14.8 inches, 21.1 lb – the most nugget-ice in the smallest space.
Reliability and long-term cost. Opal Ultra has a 3.8-star average across a small but growing review base, with some users reporting compressor failures within 18 months and mold inside the reservoir. Frigidaire bullet-ice units have 4.0-4.4 stars across much larger review bases, with a smaller failure rate but the same general caveat – keep the receipt, descale regularly, and use distilled water if you have hard tap water.
How to Clean and Maintain a Nugget Ice Maker
If you read one section of this article, read this one. Mold and mineral scale are the two failure modes that ruin otherwise excellent ice makers. We learned this from our own test kitchen and from hundreds of r/Appliances and r/IceChewersAnonymous posts.
Weekly descale routine (any machine). Unplug the unit, drain the reservoir, mix a descaling solution of one part white vinegar to three parts water (or use a dedicated ice maker cleaner like Nickel-Safe), run the cleaning cycle if your model has one, then run two freshwater rinse cycles. Wipe down the bin, scoop, and drip tray with hot soapy water. Air dry fully before reassembling.
Use distilled or filtered water if you have hard tap water. Reddit owners who switched from tap water to distilled water report dramatically less scale buildup and clearer ice. The Opal Ultra’s built-in scale-inhibiting filter helps, but it does not eliminate the problem entirely – especially if your tap water is very hard.
For GE Opal owners: deal with the reservoir. The most common complaint in r/Appliances about the GE Opal is mold inside the inaccessible reservoir that even self-cleaning cycles do not fully reach. The community-recommended fix is to do a manual deep clean every 3 months: drain the unit, use a long flexible brush to scrub the reservoir walls through the fill port, then run two descale cycles back-to-back.
For Frigidaire owners: transfer ice fast. Frigidaire countertop ice makers do not refrigerate their bins, so ice begins melting within hours. Plan to scoop ice into freezer bags or a cooler if you are not consuming it within 2-3 hours of production.
Replace water filters on schedule. If you use a third-party filter on the Opal Ultra, expect “add water” false alerts. Stick with the OEM P4INKFILTR filter and replace it every 6 months.
What to Look for in the Best Ice Maker 2026
Six factors matter when you are choosing between nugget ice makers, bullet-ice makers, and cube-ice makers. Here is how we weigh each one, in the order that affects daily use the most.
1. Daily output (lbs per day). 26 lb/day covers a single-person household or a couple who drinks iced coffee daily. 33-44 lb/day is right for families or anyone who entertains weekly. Anything under 25 lb/day will feel slow once you start hosting.
2. First batch time. Frigidaire bullet-ice units hit 6 minutes. The Opal Ultra is at 10 minutes. Gallery nugget models are 10-15 minutes. If you only need a small amount of ice fast, faster is better.
3. Noise level (dB). Anything under 50 dB is apartment-friendly. 50-60 dB is noticeable but tolerable for daily use. Above 60 dB gets old fast in an open-plan kitchen. The Opal Ultra’s 48 dB is the quietest in our test, the EFIC235’s 60 dB is the loudest.
4. Smart features. WiFi and app control are genuinely useful on the Opal Ultra for scheduled production and cleaning reminders. On bullet-ice units, smart features are usually absent and not really needed since the operation is one-touch anyway.
5. Cleaning and maintenance. Self-cleaning cycles (EFIC103) cut maintenance time. Scale-inhibiting filters (Opal Ultra) extend the interval between deep cleans. A drain plug on the back or bottom of the unit (most EFIC models) makes end-of-cycle flushes much easier than no plug at all.
6. Size and footprint. Measure your counter space before you order. The Opal Ultra is 17.5 inches deep. The EFIC235 is 19 inches tall. Most other Frigidaire EFIC units fit in a 13 x 14 inch footprint. For RV, dorm, or tiny-home use, the EFIC102 (14.1 inches deep) is the most compact option we tested.
For buyers who want a deeper dive into ice makers beyond the GE Opal vs Frigidaire matchup, our guide to the best nugget ice makers and our best countertop ice makers roundup cover the wider market. If you also want frozen treats alongside your ice, our best ice cream makers review is worth a look, and for party planning our guide to best portable ice makers for parties pairs nicely with the high-capacity picks on this list.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which nugget ice maker is better, GE Opal or Frigidaire?
The GE Opal 2.0 Ultra is the better nugget ice maker if you specifically want true Sonic-style soft, airy chewable pellets and are willing to pay a premium. The Frigidaire EFIC235 is the better value for under $350, producing dense chewable nuggets at 44 lb/day. For cube or bullet ice, the Frigidaire EFIC189 wins with 4.4 stars across nearly 17k reviews at a much lower price.
Is the GE Opal worth the money?
The GE Opal 2.0 Ultra is worth the money if you drink iced coffee or cocktails daily and want restaurant-quality chewable ice at home. It runs quieter than Frigidaire nugget makers (48 dB), has WiFi scheduling, and produces 38 lb/day. It is not worth it if you only need basic ice for water bottles – a $100 Frigidaire bullet maker will do that job for a fraction of the cost.
Which is quieter, Frigidaire or GE Opal nugget ice maker?
The GE Opal 2.0 Ultra is quieter. In our testing it measured about 48 dB at three feet during active ice production, while the Frigidaire EFIC235 measured about 60 dB under the same conditions. The Opal Ultra is the right pick for apartments, open-plan kitchens, and anyone sensitive to background hum.
How fast do GE Opal and Frigidaire make ice?
The Frigidaire EFIC235 produced its first batch in about 10 minutes, slightly faster than the EFIC2200 at 15 minutes. The GE Opal 2.0 Ultra is ready in about 10 minutes for the first batch. Frigidaire bullet-ice units (EFIC189, EFIC128, EFIC102) are the fastest overall at 6 minutes from cold start.
Do nugget ice makers need a water line or plumbing?
No. All countertop nugget ice makers we tested, including the GE Opal 2.0 Ultra, Frigidaire EFIC235, and Frigidaire EFIC2200, are plumbless. They use a removable reservoir or optional side tank that you refill by hand. Built-in or under-counter nugget ice makers are the only models that need a water line.
How do you clean a nugget ice maker?
Run a weekly descale cycle using one part white vinegar to three parts water, or a dedicated ice maker cleaner. Drain the reservoir, run the cleaning cycle if your unit has one, then run two freshwater rinse cycles. Wipe down the bin, scoop, and drip tray with hot soapy water. For GE Opal, do a manual deep clean every 3 months using a long flexible brush through the fill port to scrub the reservoir walls, since the self-clean cycle does not fully reach that area.
How long do nugget ice makers last?
Most countertop nugget ice makers last 2-4 years with regular maintenance. GE Opal owners in r/Appliances report compressor issues inside 18 months on a minority of units, while Frigidaire EFIC235 and EFIC2200 owners report 1-2 year failures on a meaningful share of units. Using distilled water, weekly descaling, and replacing filters on schedule are the biggest factors in lifespan.
Final Verdict: Which Ice Maker Should You Buy in 2026?
After six weeks of testing, the GE Opal vs Frigidaire question has a clear answer – but the answer depends on what you are optimizing for. If you specifically want true Sonic-style chewable nugget ice and value quiet operation plus WiFi scheduling, the GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra is the best premium pick and worth the premium price. If you want everyday bullet or cube ice at the lowest possible price with the deepest review base behind it, the Frigidaire EFIC189 is our editor’s choice and the safest buy on the market.
For budget shoppers, the Frigidaire EFIC128 delivers identical bullet-ice performance to the EFIC189 in a slightly smaller footprint at a lower price. For nugget fans on a tighter budget, the Frigidaire Gallery EFIC2200 produces chewable ice at a meaningful discount from the Opal Ultra, though you trade some reliability. For party hosts who need maximum output, the Frigidaire EFIC235 at 44 lb/day with the included side tank is the highest-capacity nugget maker we tested.
Whichever machine you choose, plan for weekly descaling, distilled water if you have hard tap, and a covered warranty – the best ice makers 2026 has to offer will all run better and last longer with a small weekly maintenance habit. For buyers still weighing ice type versus cube machines, our best nugget ice makers guide and the wider best countertop ice makers roundup will help you make the final call.